Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Federman's avatar

You have reached Ground Zero regarding the issue of faith. As you describe it, it seems a form of palliative care. For me, such care is, at best, intermediate because it gives a sense of security and well-being but does not do more than temporarily address or cure the foundational duality and existential bifurcation of Man and God. In other words, it sets a noble goal that can become its own worst enemy.

Yes, we have emotional intelligence that gives us conceptual linkage of consciousness and instinctual behavior. And, yes awareness of this connectivity brings comfort. But it does not get one beyond a certain degree of subject-object cognitive understanding into the realm of ongoing practiced indivisibility of perception. Worshipper and worshipped must be one and the same. Otherwised Gof and Man are both indeterminates.

My worry has always been that worship can be a double agent for belief and alienation by maintaining a separation between believer and believed in. We beg God; we bargain with Heaven; we are bullied by religion. Why? Because God is still “other” and must be "reached" or "realized." How many of the sages we have studied had to give up trying to find masters and methods to achieve enlightenment. They, like us, found answers in solitude?

If Zen taught me one thing, it is this: God is experienced as the self-sustaining ground of being on which we stand as conscious beings. I believe in the use of psychedelics because they can produce a transformative morphological experience where one’s whole being becomes conduit of cosmological perception and union. During this experience, God takes "form," as our guru said, as indivisibility in a heightened state. God is no longer associated with any longing because He has become belonging. He is not Creator or Judge or anything that is not intrinsic to ourselves.

What I am trying to say is that the ultimate consolation for all suffering is a permanent change in consciousness that leads to a non-icorruptible continuously interactive awareness. While religions and yogas espouse this organic unity, they rarely culminate in experiencing it in full, final realized form. For me, "God" is a vanishing point of all separation. As Rinzai said, "Searching for Budha is like putting a head on top of the one you already have." Atheism is a rigorous spirituality in which one switches from routes to roots. I no longer want a Sabbath Day God. Sabbath is all of time itself. I want to live nowhere else but in deeply felt sidereal space and time.

Expand full comment
Mary Boardman's avatar

I used to think that belief in a higher power was superfluous, unnecessary for health and well being. I then became a therapist and worked with folks who had been touched by suicide (attempting themselves or surviving a loved one) and I discovered that when one is faced with despair (in themselves or others) faith is not optional. Despair creates a blackhole that can engulf and destroy everything around it. The only way to generate light in that vortex is through faith - in oneself, in the goodness of those around them, in a benevolent force in the universe but most powerfully of all, in God. Interestingly, science bares this out: human beings are wired for belief in a higher power.

Is religion important? No, but having community is a powerful protective factor towards mental and physical health.

I am not a conformest and tend to chafe around organized religion but if you can look past the assholes, morons and lunatics there is something practical and healthful in the practice of faith.

Expand full comment

No posts